Non judgmental and critical listening

The current crisis has put a magnifying glass on the importance of looking after our own mental health as well as being able to support others. During times when stress and anxiety are heightened, the skill of listening non-judgementally is vital.

Non-judgemental listening is trying to really understand the other person, going beyond just hearing the words spoken, instead understanding exactly what the other person is saying.

If a friend, colleague, or family member comes to you for support, it’s important to put your own personal thoughts and feelings aside.

Tips to help you listen and communicate non-judgementally

Attitudes

  • Accept the person as they are
  • No moral judgements
  • Be genuine and empathetic
  • Acknowledge their anxieties are real to them
  • Avoid confrontation unless necessary.

Verbal Skills

  • Listen without interrupting
  • Give minimal prompts
  • Check you understand what is said
  • Summarise facts and feelings
  • Ask how they are feeling
  • Allow silences.

Non-verbal skills (body language)

  • Attentive to what and how they say it
  • Keeping comfortable eye contact
  • Sit with an open body, and not directly opposite.

The supportive power of the pause

When trying to help someone with a stressful or emotional issue, try not to react to what the other person is saying. We should pause and continue to listen and respect them quietly. The aim is not to judge or criticise the other person, but to simply listen and receive what they are saying.

Non judgmental and critical listening

Your ‘frame of reference’ is unique to you, and may be very different to someone else.

Many of us can slide into a mode of listening to respond rather than listening to understand. Listening to respond means that we are partially absent, just waiting our turn to give the person we are trying to help our opinion of the situation, which is not always helpful.

In conversations, the way we listen, and respond is influenced by what is known as ‘your frame of reference’, which gives us our own unique window or view of the world. It was first described by two psychologists, Jacqui and Aaron Schiff in 1970, who explained that we all have an individual filter on reality; how we make sense of ourselves, other people, our lives and the world around us. Each of us have a unique set of feelings, beliefs and behaviours which are shaped by numerous factors including our age, gender, work, education, values, culture, beliefs, experience, achievements, relationships, family situation and upbringing. All these unique factors have moulded the way we look out and experience our world.

By understanding your own ‘frame of reference’, you will be better able to support others

Not recognising the fact that we all have our own personal frame of reference can lead to us being somewhat opinionated and narrow minded. If you have an appreciation of the factors that influence your own viewpoint, you will be in a better position to set aside your views and support someone if they ask you for help with their problems.

Having this appreciation that we are all unique in the way that we make sense of the world is a great starting point in helping to understand and manage our own personal stress and anxiety and help others.

Often, it’s professional mental health workers and counsellors who are trained in the key principles of non-judgemental listening. More recently, Mental Health First Aiders have been receiving training in this area too, but it’s actually becoming increasingly important that all of us have knowledge in how to listen without judgement.

Awareness of non-judgemental listening could come into play if we’re faced with a critical situation where someone needs support (e.g talking down suicidal thoughts), as well as during everyday conversations where people may not be feeling well emotionally.

Non judgemental listening is powerful, and can be the difference between an escalation of mental ill-health and a person receiving life-changing support. Below we use 6 steps approved by the MHFA to teach you how you can practice your own non-judgemental listening.

What is non-judgemental listening?

Non-judgemental listening is the practice of listening without judgement and being able to separate our own feelings on a subject when we are listening.

Internally, we all come with what’s called our Frame of Reference. Our Frame of Reference is a term coined by Aaron and Jacqui Schiff and it refers to the way each of us filters our reality. Our frame of reference is made up of a number of different factors like education, life experiences and our beliefs.

Without even knowing it, our Frame of Reference is what influences our judgment of the world around us, and when we’re faced with a situation that is contrary to our Frame of Reference, we can find it difficult to hold our judgment and stop our own views and beliefs from emerging. 

Overcoming our Frame of Reference is key to listening non judgmentally, and there are 3 ingredients we can use to ensure that we are doing our best to minimise it and focus solely – and openly – on the other person.

Non judgmental and critical listening

(Source)

The Core Ingredients:

For a speaker to be able to talk openly there are three conditions that a listener must meet to form a safe environment. Without these, the speaker may not feel comfortable enough to be able to talk freely or fully.

Related: If you’re worried about a situation, cross reference some of the early warning signs of declining mental health here.

The conditions that must be met are:

  1. Acceptance: Acceptance is the hardest part of minimising our Frame of Reference. The speaker may have views and experiences that vary wildly from ours, and we must accept, respect and understand those.
  2. Empathy: To empathise, we must understand another person’s experience by hearing what the person is saying without inserting our own experience into the position. The best way to empathise is to imagine ourselves in the person’s situation, so that we can objectively understand the speaker’s circumstances.
  3. Genuineness: Presenting an air of genuineness is achieved nonverbally by ensuring that our body language matches what we say to the speaker. If we claim to understand, but our body language is cold and closed, it presents a conflicting message and doesn’t convey non-judgemental listening.

What benefits does non-judgemental listening bring?

Non-judgemental listening takes time and practice to learn because we are naturally hardwired to view the world within our Frame of Reference. However, getting non-judgemental listening right provides a host of benefits when trying to help and understand others. They are:

  • Being fully able to understand others without being distracted or influenced by our experiences and subconscious thoughts.
  • Allowing for the creation of a safe space where a speaker is likely to feel comfortable enough to speak openly.
  • Offering the speaker an opportunity to work through and understand both their thoughts and feelings relating to their situation in a safe environment.
  • Non-judgemental and empathetic listening can have a positive effect on a speaker’s mental health – something vitally important that can lead to a person receiving the right support.
Non judgmental and critical listening

(Source)

How do you practice non-judgemental listening?

Practicing non-judgemental listening can take time and practice. Below are 6 steps to help you begin to practice listening without judgement or interruption.

  1. Assess your state of mind

Before being ready to listen to someone, it’s important to check whether you yourself are in the right frame of mind. Sometimes if something is bothering us, or if we have had recent negative experiences, it can affect the way we listen to other people.

Make sure that you are calm, open and ready to listen to whatever may come your way.

Related: If keeping a positive mindset is something you struggle with, try using our tips to help you maintain a more positive outlook.

  1. Check you are presenting the right attitude

The right attitude for listening empathetically is one that draws upon all of the criteria for non-judgemental listening: Acceptance, genuineness and empathy.

By adopting an attitude that is accepting you will automatically accept and respect the speaker’s feelings, experiences and values as valid. This allows you to then envision yourself in the speaker’s situation, which automatically leads to you being more genuine and subsequently, empathetic.

  1. Use verbal listening skills

Small and simple verbal cues are skills which can help you to display to another person that you’re listening, without needing to interrupt them. 

Things like asking pertinent questions to clarify your understanding, using prompts such as “yes” and “I see”, listening to tone of voice, allowing time for a person to consider before continuing and summarising what a person has said and repeating it back are all fantastic verbal listening skills that can harness a connection. These all display to a speaker that you are attentive, engaged and listening to what they have to say. 

  1. Use non-verbal listening skills

Non-verbal listening skills can also outwardly display that you are engaged, listening and not passing judgement. 

The key to non-verbal listening is entirely in our body language. Positive body language communicates to another person that we are listening. 

Positive body language cues can include using a comfortable amount of eye contact; sitting down instead of standing up; allowing each person to have adequate space, and sitting at an angle instead of directly opposite. Maintaining an open body posture – for example not crossing your arms, which can come across as standoffish – is also just as important to display openness and acceptance. 

In addition, small prompts such as nodding your head can also communicate to the speaker that you are listening, and natural comfortable silences and supportive spaces can allow the speaker time to reflect. 

  1. Empathise with, but don’t minimise, the speaker

Overshadowing the speaker through regular interruptions, finishing their sentences, using throwaway comments or talking over the speaker with your own experiences can minimise what a person is trying to tell you and may not provide the safe environment needed to fully allow for open communication.

Create an accepting environment by not entering a conversation with expectations about what a speaker might reveal and how you may react to those. Instead, go in open minded and provide room for the speaker to listen. Withhold your own experiences and thoughts until relevant points where you can empathise with the speaker in the sharing of appropriate experiences.

  1. Respect cultural differences

Finally, be aware of cultural differences when preparing to listen non-judgmentally to someone whose ethnicity or cultural experience may differ from yours. Across different cultures, certain verbal and non-verbal behaviours – such as eye contact levels and personal space – can communicate different things. To ensure you are communicating effectively you could ask the speaker what is appropriate and comfortable for them.

Hone your non-judgemental listening: become a Mental Health First Aider

As part of Mental Health First Aid courses, Mental Health First Aiders receive training in how to listen and communicate non-judgmentally. In both workplace and social settings, these skills can provide someone with a safe space to talk, and be signposted to correct resources which could greatly benefit their mental health.

Find out more about the benefit Mental Health First Aiders can have to organisations, or enquire about taking one of our courses today.